|The INTEGRITY PAPERS - James N. Rose||Genre - H Benking US Website||http://www.ceptualinstitute.com|
S P E C I A L S E S S I O N
(on behalf of the key-noter Noel Brown)
Proposing a Conceptual Superstructure
Work-Report of a Vision to explore issue-scapes like virtual landscapes
by making use of Surveyors' abilities and Views
PREFACE - INTRODUCTION - ORIENTATION of this keynote :
Noel Brown 1994 requested from science (surveyors and remote sensing specialists in particular) to:
The proposed Conceptual Superstructure allows:
- establish common frames of reference to better gauge the human prospectus,
- develop a common understanding of the state of the environment,
- find unprecedented levels of global co-operation, common strategies for shaping a future, which is prosperous, equitable and sustainable,
- mobilise our best and brightest,
- harness our considerable scientific capabilities, the development of our most advanced technologies, those which enable us to study more systematically and in real time - just how the earth really works,
- initiate a more solid scientific foundation for the policies and strategies necessary for Earth System Management, and the design and maintenance of a sustainable future.
- transdisciplinary panning and zooming with varying foci
- interaction along and across hierachical scales
- documentation and more transparency, and
- communication within common frames of reference.
Proposing a Conceptual Superstructure - A Work-Report of a Vision
to explore issue-scapes as virtual landscapes by making use of surveyors' abilities and Views
A conception is presented to organise and visually access data and bodies of knowledge in their specific context. Hyperlinks between two reference systems (a topographical landscape and a thematic and fictive (land)scape allow uniform retrieval in one conceptual scaffold. Interface design theory and discussions on mental models and cognitive viewpoints form the theoretical aspect of the paper. Practical considerations range from knowledge organisation to the design of a world-view, which is consistent, comprehensive, and allows detailing with variable foci and theme compositions.
The objective is to counteract missing perception of time and magnitudes and address terminological bias by increasing awareness about scales, proportions and consequences through conceptualisation and imagination. Applications in education and resource management are especially suited to improve the conception and test its acceptance or usefulness.
Proposition d'une superstructure conceptuelle - Rapport de travail sur une Vision
afin déxplorer la problématique des paysage suivant une approche virtuelle en utisisant les vues et expertises professionelle des géomètres
Heiner Benking - Germany
On présente un concept pour accéder visuellement des données et des corps de connaissance dans leur contexte specifique. Relations entre deux systemes de réference topologie et thématique offrent un accès universelle dans un cadre conceptionel. La theorie des interfaces homme-maschine et la discussion sur des modèles mentales et des aspects cognitive forment l árrière-plan de cet article. Les consideration varie de l'organisation de connaissance à la construction d'une "vue du monde" qui est consistent, comprehensive et qui permet des foci different et la composition de different sujets.
L'objective est de surmonter des déficits de perception en terme de temps et proportions, des ambiguités linguistique, et de donner une meilleure idée de dimensions, proportions et leurs consequences par une augmentation des capacité de cognition et d'imagination. L´application en education et en gestion des resources donneront une idée de l'acceptance et de utilisé du concept.
Vorschlag einer konzeptionellen Dachstruktur - Ein Arbeitsbericht einer Vision
um Themenlandschaften wie virtuelle Landschaften zu erkunden indem Fähigkeiten und Sichtweisen von Vermessungsingenieuren eingesetzt werden
Es wird eine Konzeption vorgeschlagen, um Daten und Wissensbereiche zu organisieren und optisch/visuell auch in ihrem Umfeld anzusprechen. (Hyper-)links zwischen zwei Referenzsystemen, der geographischer Land-schaft und einer fiktiven Themen-/Problemlandschaft erlauben universalen Zugriff in einem Bezugssystem. Schnitt-stellen-Design Theorie und "kognitive Einsichten" bilden den theoretischen Hintergrund. Praktische Aspekte finden sich in Fragen der Wissensorgani-sation und im Entwurf von konsistenten, umfassenden und einfachen aber hier auch maßstabsfreien und thematisch komponierbaren Weltbildern.
Ziel ist es, der mangelnden Wahrnehmungsfähigkeiten für Veränderungen und Größenordnungen und der begriff-lichen Verwirrungen entgegenzuwirken, sowie das Bewußtsein für Dimensionen, Proportionen und deren Konsequenzen durch Einführung eines Bezugsrahmens und der Förderung der Vorstellungskräfte zu schärfen. Anwendungen in der Ausbil-dung und im Erd-Management sind besonders geeignet, die Konzepte auf Ihre Akzeptanz und Nützlichkeit zu überprüfen.
List of Content0. PreliminariesAnnex 1: Words or Pictures? - Both!
1. Introduction - The MISSION
2. The Problem
3. The VISION
3.1 The VISION - Part A: The Fictive Landscape
Matrix-cell combinations and flexible categories to structure information visually
How did the "Blackbox Nature" evolve?
3.2 The VISION - Part B: Visual Access and Assimilation
The ECOCUBE to present and communiate complex subjects and issues
3.3 The VISION - Part C: Twin Reference Systems form a wider Picture of the World
4. Some further explainations and possible applications
Annex 2: Information Coding Classification (ICC)
References and Literature
Originally merely planned to assist Dr. Noel Brown of the UN - Environment Program in New York, for his key-note under the Title: Challenges in Search for Policy, this paper was prepared on extremely short notice to fill the vacancy and to present the perspective of a surveyor on this subject. It reflects and pre-views meetings in Ottawa and Bratislawa and is based on work done for the Global Change Touring Exhibition and the World Futures Studies Conference in Turku (Benking 1993).
The paper has to stand in its own right as a key-note address to appeal to fellow surveyors in view of the mission as given below and the possible areas of activities presented before by (Peter Byrne 1993 see this volume). It invites to take given capabilities of surveyors and apply it to new terrain and horizons, making use of new technologies. This special session was to challenge the audience and prepare for change. It was prepared as a working report, using available viewgraphs to a large extent, which help to explain what kind of projects, research, and developments have lead to the approach.
As a technician and engineer, the author proposes to make use of genuine capabilities of surveyors, like using grids and spatial-spacial systems with variable scales and foci. By adopting new ways of making sense and use of data; not getting drowned in the hourly increasing information, but to gain knowledge and direction from it, by filtering, qualifying, organising and storing it appropriately. This paper reviews the power of visualisation, organisation and structure of information; ways of blending human creativity and intuitive analysis with computer systems , without forgetting educational and awareness implications, to better learn and act on it. Children have been introduced to the concept and have accepted it by acknowledging the line of thought and that their View of Life needs an extension, a more universal paradigm .
One important clarification regarding the topic and its outreach:
The paper and the concept does not in any way reflect and is applicable to subjects such as reason, which is ab-stract and disembodied. It solely proposes another organisation concept and reference system for real world, observable data, and invites additionally preselection visual access and imaginative manipulation approaches. To emphasize this statement is important to the author, because many discussions center around the term View of Life, World-View, or Picture of the World; assuming also metaphysical aspects, which are not helpful in this context. According to the (Encyclopedia of Philosophy 1992) a View of Life summarises knowledge which can be objectively described about real or physical objects or content and is based on natural sciences and theory. Beside the conventional geocentrical and heliocentrical Views of Life, an eco -centrical scale-independent View of Life, presented in the abstract form of the ECO-CUBE, is put forward the exploit the concept and potential of Space, even beyond the "big picture" outlined by (Tosta 1993). The proposed Conceptual Superstructure allows:
1. Introduction - The MISSION
- transdisciplinary panning and zooming with varying foci
- interaction along and across hierachical scales
- documentation and more transparency, and
- communication within common frames of reference.
In the context of this Special Session and in line with (Peter Ellyard 1994 in this volume) some aspects and appeals to science and in particular to surveyors and their future potentials, were developed and will be summarised briefly to prepare the ground for the proposal presented. Above mentioned speakers requested "new visions and new approaches, for the power to shape the future by creating new areas of competence and activity and mastering or moulding oneselve and reach new visions and perspectives". Dr. Noel Brown 1994 went on to quote René Dubois having said: "Our vast knowledge and technical capabilities give us the ability to anticipate the future, which carries with it a responsibility to manage the future". Dr. Brown even provided an example of a new quality, which he expects from new visions and approaches by explaining that the Earth Summit and the Agenda 21 would not have been possible "without humanity venturing into space, looking on the planet as One, thereby conceiving the Earth as a vulnerable whole, with the attendant responsibility of caring for the earth as a whole, and ensuring that the parts were made to operate in the service of the whole, the way nature does".
Noel Brown 1994 requested from science (surveyors and remote sensing specialists in particular) to:
Revisiting such objectives is a challenge to all humankind, far beyond the individual approach in view of the capabilities of surveyors and their future faring as a profession. Some technology assessments show which technical approaches and what kind of state-of-mind might fit best to address such challenges. This is mandatory for a profession such as surveyors, in times of rapid changes in science, technologies, and culture. This paper examines above aspects of creating new Visions on the individual level, even beyond the birds eye (from orbit), panning and zooming, and develop awareness about scales, and creating artificial perspectives and insights into critical dimensions like time and magnitude. Of further concern are terms and how ambiguities in language and jargon can be better addressed (see also Galinski 1991).
- establish common frames of reference to better gauge the human prospectus,
- develop a common understanding of the state of the environment,
- find unprecedented levels of global co-operation, common strategies for shaping a future, which is
prosperous, equitable and sustainable,
- mobilise our best and brightest,
- harness our considerable scientific capabilities, the development of our most advanced technologies, those
which enable us to study more systematically and in real time - just how the earth really works,
- initiate a more solid scientific foundation for the policies and strategies necessary for Earth System
Management, and the design and maintenance of a sustainable future.
Therefore, the central message of this paper is the use of images to better categorise (Lakoff 1987), organise, and access and assimilate (Benking, Kampffmeyer 1992) the basic domains or bodies of knowledge . By exploring cognitive viewpoints in linked (mental) models and by using structures native to the human mind, information can be better channelled and focused. How messages could be filtered according to quality and source, forming core knowledge, which should be certified as "contagious" information (Weizsäcker, E.U. 1987), after beeing checked for quality, relevance, and impact. Such clearinghouse function was urged long ago (Weinberg 1963). (For further explanations and applications see also chapter 4).
The full text with figures is available from the author by request or can be found in the FIG proceedings.
WE HAVE TAKEN HERE THE LIBERTY AND PLEASURE TO MAKE THIS PRESENTATION - WHICH WAS A REVIEW OF ONE OF THE "RIO 92" AOUTCOMES AND INCLUDES SOME RECOMMENTATIONS ON THE WEB of the consultant and author:
Foreword - Context - Topics - Terms - Scope
Originally planned to assist Dr. Noel Brown of the UN - Environment Program in New York in his key-note address: Challenges in Search for Policy, this paper was prepared at extremely short notice to fill the vacancy left by Dr. Noel Brown and to present a surveyor's perspective on this subject. It reflects on and previews meetings in Ottawa and Bratislawa and is based on work done for the Global Change Touring Exhibition and the World Futures Studies Conference in Turku (Benking 1993). The paper should stand in its own right as a key-note address to appeal to fellow surveyors in view of the challenges ahead and list of possible areas of activities for surveyors, as presented by Byrne (1993) and in this session.
This special session was to challenge the audience and prepare for change. It was prepared as a short summary of research and development projects to present a development in the tackling of complex ecological questions. It proposes making use of new technologies, but in parallel and above all training human perception and imagination about scales and effects by approaching organisation and visualisation techniques, blending human creativity and intuitive analysis with computer systems, thereby reducing complexity by employing coherence and hierarchies.
Trained as a technician and engineer, the author proposes to make use of the genuine capabilities of surveyors, such as grids and spatial-spacial systems with variable scales and foci and apply them to new terrain and levels. The objective is to adopt new ways of making sense and use of data without getting drowned in ever increasing information and to gain knowledge and direction from applying common references. Children have been introduced to the concept and acknowledge that their View of Life needs another perspective, or a more universal paradigm.
The paper and the concept do not in any way reflect or apply to subjects such as reason, which is abstract. It solely proposes another organisational concept and reference system for observable data. Emphasising this statement is important to the author, because many discussions tend to loose themselves in the terms "View of Life, World-View, or Picture of the World", assuming also metaphysical aspects, which are not helpful in this context. According to the Encyclopedia of Philosophy (1992), a View of Life summarises knowledge that can be objectively described about real or physical objects or content and is based on natural sciences and theory. Alongside the conventional geocentric and heliocentric Views of Life, an eco-centric scale-independent View of Life, presented in the abstract form of the ECO-CUBE, is put forward to exploit the concept and potential of human unique sense of space, as a vehicle for intelligent decisions, to ease understanding in a form compatible to the human thought processes. The Greeks saw a universe only in viewable things and called it cosmos. Maybe we have to extend our possibilities to view and communicate better about issues, their proportions and consequences.
The proposed Conceptual Superstructure might help by allowing:· transdisciplinary panning and zooming with varying foci
· interaction along and across hierachical scales
· documentation and more transparency, and
· communication within common frames of reference.
Am Anfang objektiver Erkenntnis
steht also nicht ein Experiment,
sondern die Beobachtung
und der Entwurf
eines ganzheitlichen Bildes,
in dem alles Wissen und
alle Beobachtungen integriert sind.
K. R. PopperObjective Knowledge1. Introduction - The MISSION:
The beginning of knowledge
is not experiment
but rather the observation
and design of a complete picture
on which all knowledge
and all observation are integrated.
K. R. Popper (translated)
In the context of this Special Session and in line with Peter Ellyard (1994, in this volume), some aspects of science and appeals in particular to surveyors and their future potentials will be summarised briefly to prepare the ground for the proposal presented. Dr. Noel Brown (1994) requested "new visions and new approaches, for the power to shape the future by creating new areas of competence and activity and mastering or moulding oneself and reach new visions and perspectives". He went on to quote René Dubois as having said: "Our vast knowledge and technical capabilities give us the ability to anticipate the future, which carries with it a responsibility to manage the future". Dr. Brown even provided an example of a new quality, which he expects from new visions and approaches, by explaining that the Earth Summit and the Agenda 21 would not have been possible "without humanity venturing into space, looking on the planet as One, thereby conceiving the Earth as a vulnerable whole, with the attendant responsibility of caring for the earth as a whole, and ensuring that the parts were made to operate in the service of the whole, the way nature does".
Noel Brown (1994) requested that scientists (surveyors and remote sensing specialists in particular):
· establish common frames of reference to better gauge the human prospectus,
· develop a common understanding of the state of the environment,
· find unprecedented levels of global co-operation, and common strategies for shaping a future, that is prosperous, equitable, and sustainable,
· mobilise our best and brightest,
· harness our considerable scientific capabilities, the development of our most advanced technologies, especially those which enable us to study more systematically and in real time - just how the earth really works,
· initiate a more solid scientific foundation for the policies and strategies necessary for Earth System Management, and the design and maintenance of a sustainable future.
Revisiting such objectives is a challenge to all humankind, far beyond the individual approach in view of the capabilities of surveyors and their future success as a profession. Some technology assessments show which technical approaches and what kind of state-of-mind might best address such challenges. This is mandatory for a profession such as surveyors in times of rapid changes in science, technology, and culture. This paper examines the above aspects of creating new visions on the individual level, even beyond the bird's eye (view from orbit). By allowing panning and zooming the use of the proposal creates familarity with scales, and creates artificial perspectives and insights into critical dimensions such as time and magnitude. Also of basic concern are terms and how ambiguities in language and jargon can be better addressed (see also Galinski 1991).
Therefore the central message of this paper is the use of images to better categorise (Lakoff 1987), organise, and access and assimilate (Benking, Kampffmeyer 1992) the basic domains or bodies of knowledge. By exploring cognitive viewpoints in linked (mental) models and by using structures native to the human mind, information can be better channelled and focused. Messages may be filtered according to quality and source, forming core knowledge (Jaenecke 1994), which should be certified as "contagious" information (Weizsäcker, E.U. 1987), after being checked for quality, relevance, and impact. Such a clearinghouse function was suggested long ago (Weinberg 1963). (For further explanations and applications see also chapter 4).
2. The Problem
Many ideas have been put forward to address the problems of terminology and organisation in which data, information, messages, knowledge, wisdom and their communication and transition into other states are of major concern (Merian 1962, Didsbury 1982). Being part of the solution is worth some study and involves critical ergonomic and human issues. The author has to restrict himself in mentioning the power, including pre- and unpremeditated mis- and under-use of data and their graphical representation "decision graphics, visual demagogy" (Benking, Steffen 1985). The topics of knowledge misery, core, peripheral, pseudo-knowledge and data-hygiene are of paramount importance and have also been nicely collated by Jaenecke (1994) and are more generally described in (CONNEX 94).
The lack of perception and sense of orientation has to do with the loss of values and the lack of ability to find a place, a position, and a perspective in society. We find children revolting against anonymous oppression and reacting violently when overexposed to media, before reverting to apathy; on the other hand, children are more aware and concerned about a human scale society (Knowledge Spiral 1993).
The study of global communication and the media age, and appropriate concepts and mechanisms on the ethical and political level to check negative effects are considered mandatory. Without being aware and applying control and filtering, information overload will have serious implications, both in regard to generations loosing a sense of purpose in life and contact with the real world. As recent studies indicate, the human brain is very flexible and restructures/adapts to a measurable degree in very short periods of time, therby increasing the ability to live in dissonance and as an observe only. Remarkable differences between age-groups are already discernible and show that media exposure without physical analogue leaves new generations handicapped. We might call it a growing unconsciousness, but how can we counteract it? - As the philosopher Habermas has pointed out: modern society is confronted with a de-coupling of the expert knowledge-culture and reality. We seem to live more and more in a world which is over-specialised and thereby compartmented, obstructing transparency and practical insights. A lack of organisation and attachment might be the central problem; managing space and objects, physically and mentally, might be the treatment indicated.
The above are not all new problems, but these remain a challenge to scientists, and to some extent also to workers and explorers of physical and theoretical spaces. Geographers were the first to extend the scope of their science, Surveyors should continue to provide the fundament: grids, dimensions, directions and object catalogs.
3. The VISION
This vision implies a concept aimed at organizing and visualising human problems and potential (UIA 1992) but also activities and visions (Albery 1992) by making use of imagination, grids and catalogues, and referencing. The scaffolding approach which can accommodate flexible foci, themes, positions, and perspectives is critical.
Designing crystal cells or "pigeon holes" to contain data or knowledge has some appeal. As a warehouse has shelves which we can approach by identifying visual, tactile, and motor spaces, we can learn to move objects in a imaginary "universal" warehouse. Learning to make better use of sensori- audiomotoric perception of space is the basic step. Keeping the "store" (repositories) in order with good care and communication is a challenging task. Design of an optimal "store" and developing and maintaining pathfinders (terms already in use for data management) to better navigate in the universe of observable things, might be the way. Properly designed data systems can help to manage and train our perception in this respect. How we view and use space is of critical importance.
This Proposal of how to structure and handle the plethora of available daily increasing data and information consists of three basic parts:
A. To define the ECO-CUBE as the basic reference space for thematic data and information with the axis definitions of discipline/subject, time and magnitude/size. The intention is to plot specified data or knowledge in a normalised, orthogonal, repeatable and simple form - Part A.
B. To "oversee" and orient/accustom oneself in the specific domains visually (without being limited by discipline definitions and specific jargon), which means avoiding as best as possible terminological ambiguities or cultural bias by rough navigation and orientation of the subjects in question before accessing catalogues and thesauri (L. videre= to see and recognise) - Part B.
C. To link a topographic reference with a thematic reference. This strategy is considered necessary to match and classify objects in the real world more appropriately, congruently and predictively and to address more universally objects, subjects, and issues concerning Man and Nature - Part C.
3.1 The VISION - Part A: The Imaginary Theme-scape
The Concept and Development of the Hyperlink ECO-CUBE
The author has "borrowed" the definitions for the three axes of the Cube: TIME; SCALE, and SUBJECT (diCastri, Hadley 1985-88) and has tested the universal applicability during the last seven years (see also literature and chapter 4). Describing the System Earth in the Global Change touring exhibition for the German Chancellery, Lange, Benking, et.al. (1990) used this three dimensional scheme and called the subject dimension (bio)diversity. In this way the dimensions could be named Complexity, Differentiation, and Dynamics. As we learned recently the Australian geographer R.G. Cant had already used a similar Cube concept with the dimensions: Phenomenon, Position and Time in 1969! The particular terms or labels for the dimensions are of little importance as long as they are meaningful, simple and universal; what is critical is the orthogonal design with "normalised" entities and the usage of the concept beyond words.
Creative catalytic imagery and the communication bandwidth are decisive if we are to arrive at other qualities by using our "Inner Eye". One positive effect of using an "agreed upon" framework: views and positions can be located, better communicated, and repeated.
Given the volume and heterogeneity of highly differentiated and ambiguous information, a new concept merging human and machine power seems appropriate. But we must keep in mind that man, being the threshold to creativity and imagination, makes use of number-crunching and visual volume processing only as a supportive action rather than what is critical for the overall concept.
Architects and geographers, as well as town and state planners, are used to organising and structuring data and to looking for a synthesis in complex, heterogeneous and voluminous issues. The planner Doxiades for example, with the Ekistic grid, made use of visual recognition according to a comprehensive structuring system. Visual inspection and differentiation is one of the key elements in the chain of methods proposed. Using as an example the representation of the Ekistics was therefore the logical step. Projecting the Ekistic grid into the third dimension Time was also already anticipated. For more information and how content can be displayed in one graph, instead of key-words or abstracts, presenting context and qualitative information, see Doxiades (1968).
Besides the organisation and classification schemes of Ekistics, there are various schemes introduced to structure available subjects in a congruent and systematic way. Best are systems which are close to the inherent structures of the real world and which allow the combining of knowledge beyond the collections and terms, or jargon of specific disciplines or groups. Only a few organisation schemes allow for the presention of relations between the main categories in visual form.
One such practical universal system, even broader than the Ekistik classification, has been developed as the Information Coding Classification System (ICC) during the last 20 years by Dahlberg (1994 and Annex) . Such a system can be easily translated into other schemes and referenced to other more detailed discipline oriented classification systems. It is important to note that such systems can coexist and can be linked with modern hyperlink technology, and can help flexibly structure the critical non-linear terminological axis in the twined three-dimensional reference system combination proposed in Part C.
Matrix-cell combinations and flexible categories to structure information visually
Our eye can identify information and structures easily. The use of a grid to structure information helps to organise information according to the dimensions and scales selected. Using a grid is actually a trick to better utilise human capabilities. By properly structuring and positioning the information, later processing can be made much easier.
The basic grid of the first box has 3x3x3 cells. If we use 5x5x5 cells, we can already structure and detail very complex situations and see "at a glance" areas of concern or interest. The 5 cell cube shows for example a working area of towns and regions in the natural and social context studying settlements before Christ and the disciplines involved in the research. This image can show where a colleague is working, and might be the search key for an indexing and graphical retrieval system.
The Rubik's Cube of Ecology has just 3 categories for each side: Inanimate-, animated Nature, and Culture; Micro-, meso-, macro-scale; past, present, and future. Ekistics have used much more detailed systems with 5 categories: Nature, Man, Society, Infrastructure, Structure (Shell). The Blackbox Nature has 7 categories: Theoretical Natural Sciences, Applied Natural Sciences, Geo-, Life-, Economic-, Social- and Cultural- Sciences or the ICC (Dahlberg 1994).
Ekistics, as a science, structures the impact of human activities. Main categories are: economic, social, political, administrative and technical sciences and art. This organising and classification scheme is used, for example, to classify articles in the Ekistics Journal visually and thereby help readers to identify topics of concern at a glance, by just browsing through the pages and looking at the grid at the top of the page. This example shows the potential of information, classified and organised in a meaningful way, in an easily accessible layout. In the field of urban planning, individual and community requirements cover large volumes of complex and interdependent data. The science of the broad and complex field of "human settlements" is called Ekistics, derived from the Greek word oikos. The Cube is just a concept across scales, holding similar structures and rules at all orders of magnitude, for example, planet, country town, house, plant..., The actual axis description is of secondary importance. It may be a logarithmic scale which covers larger quantities or periods, or other flexible categories which can provide a reference into another system.
The Dimensions - A Grid projected in time
Each Category has many sub-categories; they are structured in a hierarchical way, called a thesaurus in technical or linguistic applications. In each science we have general thesauri to differentiate fields or topics down to the finest detail. Precision in each discipline must be considered as an advantage of specialisation. But there is a disadvantage, the lack of overview and exchange with neighbouring fields. Therefore, a growing demand is building up to develop "wild" cross-disciplinary relationships and look at them in a holistic way. Bridging disciplines and hierarchical levels or horizons and interacting along and across scales is required for people studying the multi-disciplinary field of Ecology. This does not only apply to Ecology, but to the exchange between experts of different disciplines in general.
If each body of knowledge is represented in the crystal cell framework, it is easy to highlight trans-disciplinary subjects in one reference frame. Visual inspection, alongside a computer-based visualisation, can help to illuminate issues and their scope. Proposing a three-dimensional badge, like an ISBN numbers, was the next logical step for portraying bodies of knowledge in their context. Instead of sketching with a few lines and symbols a complex situation and having others guess what it means, we can describe subjects by just locating "crystal" cells in the Cube. Consequently, effects of neighbourhood or directions then come "automatically" or more associatively into view . With the focus on time and change in many sciences and applications, not only in Economy and Ecology, we have a much more complex multi-dimensional "scene". But how do we see, understand, and "envision" it? - Why not create a scene, as a composer creates a mental picture of his piece of music before he goes to the piano, or the architect sees his design and understands the spaces and rooms and functions, even before the building is erected? A design of Nature includes more dimensions than just the physical dimensions x, y, and z.
Due to the fact that we can only visualise three dimensions in a single picture, it was necessary to select three arbitrary axis descriptions. The definition of Ecology, which requires interaction along and across disciplines, magnitudes and time scales, was selected as being the most comprehensive and meaningful.
How did the "Blackbox Nature" evolve?
The ECOCUBE to present and communiate complex subjects and issues
3.2 The VISION - Part B: Visual Access and Assimilation
(Hu)man(kind) sees further than it can think, is an idiom which can be found in many languages. This paper intends to harness these visual powers, and will focus on how to identify structures in volumes of heterogeneous and inconsistent information. The combination of structures and patterns catalyses and brings about new qualities and insights.
Not only paintings or pictures, but also cross-cultural information, jokes, idioms, and metaphors can in a few lines describe an overall, or governing idea. The concept of the "Ecological View-of-Life" refers to training of the brain to "compute" in pictures, to compare structures more often, and to think in pictures and metaphors (as a very high form of abstraction which can be more easily communicated across language or cultural barriers, and which has various creative and catalytic positive side-effects.
Pragmatic aspects of proper structural analysis and of the comparison of structures to find appropriate tools and technologies has to our knowledge to date not been systematically exploited. Perception of space and navigating in spaces, cells or "rooms", or quarters (see the townscape discussion in the field of knowledge organisation), has a very basic cognitive dimension and training is required to get used to combining perceptions in stereo models and navigate in these real or artificial environments. Research efforts in the field of perception, cultural context, differentiation and navigation have been going on for some time. But only with the development of advanced graphics and hyperlink technology can some new developments be envisioned.
Visual access strategies have been previously described and presented (Benking 1993). They can be summarised here as a powerful approach, close to human conceptualisation and memorisation capabilities. Early school training, in combination with computer systems and graphical support,might augment human capabilities and help in the orientation and mastering of the information glut.
If children can be enticed by simple pictorial content, and take pleasure in exploring the concepts presented, a first step has been made. Details to any desired depth may be added using electronic referencing and documentation aids. This is an issue for media games or puzzles, triggering imagination, and training structural combinations and realizing semantic topologies.
Another critical part of this concept is the combination of linear and non-linear scales. Through inspection and visual intuitive approaches, missing data or bodies of knowledge can be identified easily. For details on disciplinarity, interdisciplinarity, multidisciplinarity, transdisciplinarity,.. and "harmonisation within and between applications and organisations". (Keune, et.al. 1991) and in particular their specific challenge to mankind see di Castri, Hadley (1986). As proposed, some separate fields of knowledge will no longer be perceived as different because of their cultural, semantic lineage; but instead their similarity and structure will be observable and lead inevitably to integration. A "Picture of the World and Knowledge Organisation" and some work on coding and classification schemes are a prerequisite (Krushanow 1993).
3.3 The VISION - Part C: Twin Reference Systems form a wider Picture of the World
Combining topographic (reality) with thematic (imaginary) referencing
A comprehensive picture of the world is necessary to map, structure and combine available information. This section argues that there is no general unified vision accepted which also incorporates dimensions like space, time and size. But this seems necessary or helpful in view of the information overload and the need to identify data and their use and relevance.
Constituents of the proposal to structure and classify uniformly are:
· Regarding space as a mechanism to reduce complexity.
If the subject is too broad, why not use combinations of spacial co-ordinate systems
or making use of human conceptual and imaginative power.
· Bridging (links, fusion, superimposition) of incompatible terminology and approaches.
With the advent of Hyperlinks and Hyperknowledge (Radermacher 1992) the field of linking subjects and clarifying the relationships among taxonomies and semantics is evolving rapidely. Surveyors in particular can develop a unique approach to handling both, spacial and spatial data, develop object catalogues, and maintain repositories. They have been explorers and navigators in many fields, always providing new and unifying visions which set new horizons and open new terrain, a new terra incognita.
Before we study inner or outer boundaries of bodies of knowledge and how the bridging and fusion could be achieved, we have to realise that geography has already started to move away from a plain geographic space science to considering space as an element of social communication. The term gr. "chora" has the meaning of "space/location" and also "content" and that is what this proposal is all about. The capabilities to navigate and register space can also be applied to mental models. We realise not only then that our thinking is very much based on spacial metaphors and paradigms. The approach arbitrarily selects sets of real-world co-ordinates and relates them to the thematic box coordinates, cells or slots of the ECO-CUBE. Experience and acceptance will show which co-ordinates should be selected for which purpose and which other "boxes" should be linked.
Six-dimensional coupled synthetic reference paradigm as a master reference scheme.
Thematic reference schemes can be linked on demand
Two combined spaces relate perception and existence; communication relates context and experience
LATE NOTE (Febr. 2001):
At that time in 1994 the development to include a third space, the Cognitive Panorama, with the help of Mrs Dahlbergs ICC was not in a stage ready to be widely pubizised. Please the figure below and consult more recent literature:
We use two referenced spaces which can be easily coded. Ranges of any of the axes can be explored and cell combinations envisioned. Using three-dimensional spaces and combining them in a meaningful way is a contribution to human mental orientation and conceptionalisation powers. Any structure beyond three dimensions is hard to imagine and even harder to communicate!
With such a holistic referencing approach we map synergistic or holistic issues by describing some aspects of integrative and transdisciplinary thought. There is no need to point out that missing links and slots are areas which raise attention visually and often prove critical since they are often disregarded. See also the analysis of "holes" or singularities and approaches with morhological boxes, synectics, etc. in many sciences, to check completeness and consistency). The term "Querdenken" in German (diagonal and integrative thinking) is considered unconventional but appropriate and sensible in a twinned co-ordinate system. Paradigms are in progress (Henderson 1992) and we need to define scales to plot proportions and consequences, otherwise we will end up in subjective cyberspaces lacking common references.
Managing Earth resources and Human Dimensions programs requires common frameworks and understanding. Testing the concept with children was worth all the effort and has proved much more basic than any singular research or theoretical approach. But combining education with an overall reference and hierarchical order system should win some critical review and hopefully improve the private, and in most cases voluntary efforts.
Combining the approaches of medicine and ecology (see footnote 1), advanced research transcending scales will bring about new views and results at all levels. With good reason one medical scientist (Carrel 1936) has noted, "that our store of knowledge has become disordered". Since we don't care about quality and order, the oversee-ability has been lost. Carrel urged "knowledge to be represented in concise and synthetic form".
One objective and challenge is to combine human capabilities and computer systems and, in parallel, train unique capabilities of the creative, but underexplored human mind. A positive side-effect might be a contribution to the interface design theory discussion and development, which requires extensive research.
To identify and map a complex scene like the environment is a challenge. We are tempted to simplify complex objects for better understanding and communication. However the problem of oversimplification should not be discarded. Tools and approaches are put forward for discussion to allow better understanding and to help select the best possible approach to the many obvious, but still not completely addressed issues, such as overpopulation, socio-economic and environmental regional conversion (ASZE 1993).
The main idea is to use (due to the limited conceptual dimensions of man) interlinked 3-dimensional models or reference systems with modern non-linear hyperlink technology - one is the conventional real world co-ordinates reference system, the other a imaginary "landscape" or world, with artificial viewpoints and perspectives. The resulting six-dimensional reference system can be handled, easily communicated, and might help to counteract the omnipresent information overkill.
Central points are imaginary or fictitious/artificial viewpoints, and a scaffolding, or superstructure, to help index, organise, and link areas of expertise, bodies of knowledge, activities or project scopes, problems and possible solutions/experience. Access, assimilation, and implementation strategies, cover the subject of database design and ergonomic, fault tolerant, multi-terminological approaches to data and knowledge and contribute to the harmonisation, comparability and compatibility debate. This approach is centered around the discussions on cognitive viewpoints and mental models, technological and policy issues, creativity and imagination and some organisational and educational aspects. The concept of using grids and co-ordinates is not at all new. The author has been working toward the Blackbox CUBE concept since 1987 and learned later that historical geography has used concepts to plot a cube with the axes phenomena, location, and time (Hartshorne 1959). New is with advances of computer technology to create hyperlinks, and have the appropriate performance to manage intelligently quality controlled data .
The paradigm of twinned reference "worlds" is to the knowledge of the author new. It might prove simple enough to be have some impact on how we manage our Planet Earth, understand our place, and jointly develop some consciousness about the proportions and consequences involved. The key is contagious communication hitting the point within "common frames of reference".
Communication should, for this purpose, be better broad-banded (visualisation is just one part of the spectrum) and can in this way help "engender" by bringing together different viewpoints and realities. Perhaps we can address the challenges to policy by training and cultivating the "Eye of Experience" (gr. phronesis) by looking at the subjects carefully and gaining experience and feeling for proportions and consequences in an imaginary space "sandbox", or situation rooms, as has been laid out by Lamson (1981).
We experience cognitive breaks and an asymmetry between specialisation and generalisation which is widening because science is still discipline-, rather than task- and solution-oriented as Vester (1980) suggested. By being confronted with facts and dimensions and being forced to map them within "common references", it may be possible to collect enough resources and to act upon the challenges laid before us. Dr. Brown (1994) saw change in Earth politics only after man in orbit saw the planet in its wholeness, fragility, and virtue. Now we have to design new pictures and secure hospitable houses and neighbourhoods.
Surveyors will have to work with "architects" (for "infrastructure", household (oikos) and human interfaces); such architects are "leading artists" (gr. architekton) who master the fine and exact arts and communicate to policy makers! They are trained to envision and design in space and time. Maybe together we can address the issues and have better command and more real understanding of the challenge to science and politics ahead (see again Lange, Benking, et.al. 1990) as clearly laid before the trade of surveyors by Brown in his opening words.
The GeoJournal Trilogy: Enhancing the Credibility of Ecology (diCastri, Hadley 1985-1988) synergized the research efforts done in various projects. The concept of Blackbox Nature and how sections, or slants of Life could be incorporated into one body of data (Benking, et al. 1985-1990). The Trilogy has initialised the line of thought presented here, and given a fine metaphor in a twofold positive sense - By describing the "Interaction along and across hierarchical scales" to understand processes, patterns and constraints, and by describing scale as a broad term representing not just size, but size with proportions and consequences. With this guideline we can plot issues, bridge topics and map physical and terminological aspects. Comparing the impact of modern communication technology on research today with the microscope in the sixteenth century, diCastri and Hadley have indeed initiated a line of thought. This comparison is a fine example for the catalytic of power of metaphors (Judge 1993). "Panning and zooming" in new, even non-linear fields or realms, is really exciting and has some charm thanks to Hadley and diCastri. They should be acknowledged more widely for their work and genuine concepts. Such Visions provide the fertile ground needed to reach for goals in the stars as set by policy makers as described. Thanks again for the drive and insights needed by people looking for orientation and directions.
Some parts of the concepts described might lead to, or have some resemblance, to older cultural wisdom. The I-Ging for example presents core knowledge in a synthetic form, beyond reason or scale. The Sufis teach. "If you want to solve a Problem, take your own Viewpoint out" and we should not forget that this is a mental exercise. Some other hints and warnings can be found in literature, like Herman Hesse's "Glass Bead Game" by accusing the intellectual elite in society of a lack of insights and pointing out that they must serve something wider and deeper than themselves. Instead he sees them leaning towards self-praise and self-glorification, towards the development and cultivation of intellectual specialities. Hesse's description of their useless and most expensive form of intellectual activity rings a bell. They relate in their glass bead game a whole range of symbols, from mathematics via history and grammar to music and meditation. The crystal cell framework has to function and present the total opposite! It has to work not primarily by free association, but by consistent and repeatable reasoning, augmenting the "Eye of Experience". Avoiding language barriers between disciplines by developing specific common referenced code might be an alternative to uncontrolled and unstructured fantasy of Cyberworlds.
The list of people guiding me and providing fundamental support willingly or without realising it will always be incomplete. The following individuals come to mind: Alfred Schinz, Robert Jungk, Edgar Westrum, Anthony Judge, Wolf Tietze, Howard Didsbury, Ernst-Ulrich v. Weizsäcker, Michael D. Gwynne, Wolf-Dieter Grossmann, Josef Schwitte, Franz-Josef Radermacher, Hartmut Keune, Ulrich Weiß, Anton Kaiser, William R. Adamson, Peter Byrn, and John Parker. I would like to thank them all for their interest, patience, serenity, and their professionalism.
Annex 1: Some further explanations and possible applications: ACTIONS
· Reviving "theorein" in its original meaning: Order or organisation without theory is not possible. Proposing a conceptual scaffolding, or superstructure, to map knowledge and action a critical step. Perhaps the cognitive viewpoint, as proposed, might provide insights. The Gr. word "theorein" demonstrates the necessary combination of to see, to have and to provide insight. The basic steps are from analysis to synthesis, from diagnosis to therapy, and from theory to Life, without thinking bigger than Life. And this has to be done by combining and relating validated and agreed upon information. The Weinberg Report (1963) and Riggs (1985) have set the direction and we will see if ways can be found to at least structure our Core Knowledge (Jaenecke 1994) in a more meaningful and consistent way. "Embryonic" Cube developments like the ECOCUBE or the World Press Centre (WPC) London concept are reviewed "in regard to what is going on" (o'Connors 1994).
· Some processes to harness ideas can be easily explained by transferring structures and processes from one context or scale to another. To plot such a solution and to determine where these structures originated is easy with the CUBE scaffolding. To explain the quality and procedure of approaches which produce ideas, like micro-macro transfers or other archetype based idea generation techniques, see Morawa (1979, 1989). His generating creativity to a measurable degree, is presented to provide examples of the Power of Visualisation. Such "Quickstorming" technology is based on archetypes (simplified icons or pictures) to structure and guide the creative process and train fast creative thinking.
· Surveyors should make use of their mapping, orientation, exploration and navigation expertise; map and exploit new domains and realms and exploit new domains. Approaches depend very much on the objectives, cultural and educational aspects, and how technologies are used for better or worse. If we surveyors additionally build Bridges and check Master Plans (Benking 1992) in new terrains and have some "construction" going regarding current issues like Information Highways and Collaboratories (NSF 1993, Benking, et al 1994), we have not lost track of the path between hazards and challenges.
· How easily, when exposed to the right Spirit of Play, transfers and insights can be obtained. See presentations to the widest range of database experts at CODATA (BENKING 1992) These database experts defined their area of expertise in the form of a 3-D tag. Similar to a 3-D ISBN number forming an access key raised new questions, stimulated laughter and interest in transfer-issues and might be able to help develop diagonal thinking.
· Another major area of possible application is the linking of structures and situations with collections of information, including encyclopaedias, which identify problem areas, solution potentials or visions, in addition to conventional databases. Examples include Encyclopedias (Albery 1993, UIA 1991), and other repositories.
· Mapping political discourse is another area where it is helpful to define more precisely the nature of the topic. By providing "location and context" for problems, solutions and resources we have a chance to outline topics in quite different ways and can insure that arguments match the issue (see also IBIS Issue-Based Information Systems (Isenmann 1993). The possibility of describing the reasoning of old and new governance systems, like Panetics (Siu 1994), which help to view and compare decision in the light of minimum impact or suffering, is another issue. Work is under way for the World Population and Development Conference in Cairo (United Nation Population Fund) to improve the communication about the impact of decisions taken in view of the carrying capacity and population density of our planet and to develop perspectives.
· The futurist and writer Robert Jungk has been thinking "deeply" by envisioning and promoting the concepts of international repositories like the "Encyclopedia of World Problems ..." and urging that the ideas related to the ECOCUBE be tested and improved by, and with children. On various occasions this has been done with some success (Benking 1993, Knowledge Spiral - International Children Communication Camp).
· Interface Design Theory, though a major aspect of the design and feasibility considerations, is not covered adequately in this paper. The user very often has no idea about the content or syntax of a specific database or repository, and would like to depict the domain of interest and not necessarily learn how he can access by specific strokes, codes and acronyms. The human mind is much faster at identifying and distinguishing when recognising what it is looking for, instead of following a specific, often unfamiliar terminology. Croze (1983) called it the sectoral data trap. See also Hoetker (1991) for cultural bias. It is important to modify query and result presentation interactively, play with queries and responses and thereby come closer to the targeted issue or concern. Combining structural and logical paradigms with virtual reality paradigms is the challenge of this applications only recently possible with modern communication systems. The discussion as to whether, and if mental models exist to portray such broad themes and how user interfaces can initiate and stimulate cognitive activities is just beginning. Some experts feel that domain semantics for themes like the environment are too complex to be held in mental models. Others prefer "trial and error" on a visual basis by depicting items, until finally the user can see what he wants. How a conceptual scaffolding might help to avoid getting lost is the key question of this article and of ongoing research.
Annex 2: Information Coding Classification (ICC)
pleae see literature or how we apply it "nowadays" in know- or interest-map new search paradigm "pattern languages", see powerpoint FOLIO
Annex 3: Thesis 1-10 - Our View of the World is too Flat was first presented at WFSF in Turku in 1994
A framework is required to allow the individual to find his place in the universe and develop an overall perspective. It is also necessary to relate information in repositories with observations about the world and with individual viewpoints. Some sense of harmony will result when one comes to understand the global perspective and realises that each individual is an integral part of the whole, just as each brick is an integral part of the wall. This realisation will help to combat feelings of apathy and futility. It is important that this concept models only the physical universe, and thus leaves open the possibility of influence by spiritual forces.
Children grow up in a world of separated fields, and are encouraged through intense competition to specialise at an early age. The increasing demand for holistic and integrated approaches to system- and process-oriented concepts is contradicted by efforts to limit the natural exploratory tendencies of children. Once these tendencies are suppressed, it is often not possible to counteract a transformation which has results in an analytic being devoid of spirituality and creativity.
Ecology is not presented as a multi-disciplinary field because only sector-oriented and causal thinking, as opposed to system-oriented thinking, are taught. Such a multi-disciplinary perspective can thus only be obtained through broad practical and physical experience. A conceptual image, which is more than just a mental framework and an associated paradigm, is therefore difficult to achieve.
Individuals feel helpless and powerless because they don't perceive their contribution or their relationship to the world as a whole. The result is apathy and abdication of responsibility based on the lack of a perception that action or inaction on the part of the individual will have an impact on the overall system.
Only through localisation of effect in space and time is a feeling of deep knowledge created. Reference to the environment or neighbourhood are essential to developing practical approaches to problems and improved learning.
There is a necessity to develop a new networking nomenclature which can additionally contain imagery of various dimensions and metaphors. Such catalytic "concept-language" simplifies and speeds communication and allows mediation of complex decision scenarios. The resulting unified "terminology/"imageology"/"metaphorology" allows multi-dimensional thought and helps to identify cultural differences in expression and understanding. The present use of language does not allow distinct terminology, only relative terms, which require pictures and metaphors to make the point, especially in multi-dimensional domains.
Since children appreciate the use of simple pictures and stories to explain complex relations, this form of communication should be seriously considered. Children seem to think visually, but this technique is underexploited and not completely understood. That catalytic powers of thinking and speaking in pictures are supressed is readily seen in comparing cultural differences in memorisation.
The process self-discovery and the development of self-esteem are strongly related to the concepts of home and intimacy. If the boundaries of thought and perception are extended, for example from village to country to planet, adequate concepts for thoughts are required for improved imagination, mapping, and living according to such expanded perceptions. Imagery which supports this expanded context, the reference to details, and related knowledge and experience, creates advanced creativity and catalytic possibilities, and thus allows for deeper insight.
One major problem is the lack of experience with and feeling for spatial and time scales. They must be experienced outside of the conventional range of individual observation, and have direct implications for relationships with and management of natural resources. Without a perception of scales and dimension, there is no space for responsibility and ethics.
Imagination and creativity are wasted if an early "fun and games" approach to obtaining a capability for making mental transitions between structures, subjects, scales, and relationships is not taken. The word intuition in the Greek and Roman sense included inspiration in a parallel mode: seeing the overall picture at a single glance, followed by perusal of the details. The trick is to learn to oscillate between these forms of mental exercise and thereby foster ingenuity. The definition of ecology as "interaction along and across hierarchical scales" requires techniques such as zooming, panning, overlaying, system dynamics oriented functional linking. The use of imagery, concepts, and metaphors to trigger mental traversal of these scales is crucial. These techniques utilise creative and analytical capabilities in parallel, and therefore result in dramatic increases in quality and speed of response.
If we can show the various phenomena of nature in a single framework, we will have a universal system for perceiving nature in time and space (Natur-Raum-Zeit). Understanding the interaction and communication between individual processes, and the unique position and importance of each contribution, a new sense of responsibility and community-oriented thinking may develop.
A new dialogue with nature requires the concept of a web forming the whole (Ilya Prigogine). With hierarchical self-similar structure (as in the Chinese Feng Shui concept), a new cosmopolitical and universal thinking may develop with images and patterns crossing new horizons and domains. If children can be enticed by such simple pictorial content, and take pleasure in exploring these concepts, a first step has been made. Detail to any desired depth may be added later using electronic referencing and documentation aids.
Annex 3: Words or Pictures? - Both!
Metaphors, idioms, and poetry present in a highly condensed form a broad spectrum of aspects which are hard to describe in any other form of communication. The ignite pictures and call memory which is powerful but individually very different. Anyway this collection might be able in its totality to cover the concept quite nicely.
FIGURES PRESENTLY unavailable
Annex 4: Highlights
References and Literature
Technical:· Proposing an additional framework for indexing in conjunction with real world co-ordinates. Mapping and referencing relates to the land-scape and to an artificial problem- or issue- scape. Change of perspectives and position are thereby encouraged
· Triggering human powers of imagination by extending, linking, and overlaying domains and challenging segmentation, compartmentalisation, and over- specialisation
· New approach by adding a third dimension (time) to conventional matrix organisation schemes (Ekistics) and utilising visual (optical) discrimination and recognition potentials
· The "Blackbox Nature" features a logical development, based on electronic archiving, hyperlink and computer graphics / multi media technology
· Facilitating and inviting switching of scales to better understand processes, patterns, and constraints
· Proposing an universal classification and coding system
· A framework to orient entries in existing data collections, such as the "Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential", "The Book of Visions", or other conventional collections from private or public institutions
Philosophical:· Interconnected "digestible" box thinking relating to adjoining spaces instead of simplistic "inside the box" or "outside the box" discrimination
· Framework which provides an internal hierarchical order like the Chinese Feng Shui and forms a scale-independent web required for the new dialogue with nature (Ilya Prigogine) - the crystal cells may be considered the meeting and anchor points
· A framework of crystal cells, representing the position of objects, issues or entities (in contrast to the unstructured free association of issued in Hesse's "Glass Bead Game"). The obvious context and linkages help in exploiting intuitive and analytical powers and invite diagonal thinking with variable scales and foci
· Extended panorama to provide common frames of references providing better focus on the point or on the issue
· For children to visualise context, complexity, and completeness by providing a common foundation by pulling together all fields of study into a more understandable unity
· For research and administration to link subjects and invite transdisciplinarity
· By zooming along and across hierarchical scales increasing scaling perceptions and thereby allowing better understanding and decision-making.
Heiner Benking Abraham, R. H.: (1992) Cellular Dynamata and Morphogenesis, Chaos
ACCIS (1988) Guide to United Nations Information Sources on the Environment, United Nations, New York
ACCIS (1990) Directory of United Nations Databases and Information Services, Advisory Committee for the Co-ordination of Information Systems, New York
Adamik, P.: Ein Netz voller Informationen - NETWORLD - Neue Medien, In: cogito, 30-33, 5-92
Adams, I.H.: (1994) . Global Thesaurus Lexicon for understanding the human condition. (= British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data), London
Westbrook, J.H., Grattige, W. eds.:A Glossary of Terms relating to Data, Data Capture, Data Manipulation, and Databases, ICSU-CODATA, Paris
A Survey of Environmental Monitoring and Information Management Programmes of International Organizations, Second Edition, UNEP- HEM, Munich, April 1991
A Vision of Virtuality: (March 1993), GMD Spiegel , Vol 23., Sankt Augustin, ISSN 0724-4339
Albery, N.:(1992) An Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential, The Book of Visions, The Institute of Social Inovations, London, ISBN 0-86369-601-5
Albrechtsen, H., Oernager, S.: (1994), Knowledge Organization and Quality Management, 3rd Int. ISKO Conference, Copenhagen, INDEKS Verlag, Frankfurt
Anderia G.:(1992) Information in 1985 - A Forecasting Study of Information Needs and Resources, OECD, Paris
Archer, A.A., Lüttig G.W., Snezhko, (eds.): (1987), Man's Dependence on the Earth - The Role of the Geosciences in the Environment, UNEP, Nairobi, UNESCO, Paris, E. Schweizerbarth'sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Stuttgart
Ashdown, M., Schaller, J.:(1990) Geographic Information Systems and their Application in MaB Projects; Ecosystem Research and Environmental Monitoring, International Co-ordinating Council, 11th Session, UNESCO Headquarters, Paris, November
Averous, M.: (1990) 2nd Generation of Environmental Information.....; OECD, Paris
ASZE (Akademie für Sicherheit und Zusammenarbeit in Europa/Berlin) (Hrsg.): (Mai 1993) Wege zum ökologisch-ökonomischen Umbau: Wie kann ein Informationssystem zur Unterstützung und Kontrolle des ökologisch-ökonomischen Umbaus in Europa durchgesetzt werden? Expertentreffen Nr. 2/1993 Berlin, ASZE-Report Nr. 12
Barlow, H., Blakemore, C., Weston-Smith, M.: (1990) Images and Understanding, Cambridge University Press,
Benking, H.: (April 1984), Die Integration steht for der Tür, Editorial 0-Nummer, CAE-Management Magazin, (on topologies, token ring networks, corporate integration and perspectives after introduction of Apollo DOMAIN in 1991, both: Vogel-Verlag, Würzburg
- , Steffen H.: (1985) Computergraphics for Precessing, Analysis, and Output of Corporate and Market Data. (daily keynote and technical conference theme as forerunner of GIS), CAMP '85 Computer Applications for Management and Productivity, WCGA World Computer Graphics Association, 24.-27.9.1985 in Berlin
- (1987), Präsentation und Technik, INFOGRAFIK, 3, 4-10, Konradin Verlag, Stuttgart
- (Sept. 1987), System-, Device-, Standard- Independent Vector- and Rastergraphics, SEAS SHARE, Vol. 2, 939-947, Edinburgh and IBM Executive Briefing Center, Brussels
- (1988), Möglichkeiten und Grenzen der Datenpräsentation im Umweltbereich. In: Jaeschke, A., Page, B. (eds.), Computer Sciences for Environmental Protection. Informatik Fachberichte 170, 155-168, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg
- , Lessing, H.: (1989) Large Scale Monitoring for Renaturation, Geoökodynamik 10, 2/3, 277-290, International Geoecology and Geomorhology Congress, Frankfurt 1989
- , Schmidt von Braun, H.: (1990) Geo-/Object-Coding for Local Change Assessment - Planning, Execution, Accounting, and Research demand Repeatability and Validity of Geotope/Biotope Information, In: GLOBAL CHANGE Conference Report Moscow 1989, published in GeoJournal 20.2, 167-173
- : (February- July 1990) Information about Environmental Information; Discussion Paper and Proposal for the First UNEP-HEM International Expert Group Meeting in Combination with the Feasibility Studies and Proposals MeDIS and ISET, hand-out and documents available through UNEP-HEM, see also (EARTHWATCH 1991), Munich-Hamburg
- (1991), Integrated Monitoring and Modelling for Environmental Research and Mangement - bridging measurement, theory, and validation- poster at Geotechnica LOCAL an GLOBAL CHANGE exhibition under contract of UNEP-HEM and in co-operation with UNEP; GSF, DAIMLER-BENZ/ DASA_MBB, Austrian Academy of Sciences and KFA, Cologne 1991
- (1991), LOCAL AND GLOBAL CHANGE, Research and Co-ordiantion Tasks of International Organisations, Presentation of 11 international organisations or bodies, (editorial advisors: Gockel, E., Lange, M., Keune, H.), geotechnica 1991, Cologne
- , Kampffmeyer, U.:(1992) Access and Assimilation: Pivotal Environmental Information Challenges - Linking, Archiving, and Exploiting Multi-Lingual and Multi-Scale Environmental Information Repositories, GeoJournal 26.3, 323-334,
- , Kampffmeyer, U.: (February 1992) Harmonization of Environmental Meta-Information with a Thesaurus-Based Multi-Lingual Multi-Media Information System; International Space Year (ISY), Earth and Space Science Information Systems Conference (ESSIS), NASA-JPL, Pasadena
- (1993) Visual Access Strategies for Multidimensional Objects and Issues.- A new World View, based on the Hyperlink ECO-CUBE, for better understanding and communication about multi-disciplines like Ecology - XIII World Conference of World Futures Studies Federation (WFSF), COHERENCE AND CHAOS IN OUR UNCOMMON FUTURES, Visions, Means, Action, Turku, Finland, August 23-27, 1993 - FAW- TR-93019, Ulm
- , Schwitte, J.:(Juni 1993) Leitziel: Interdisziplinäre Umweltwissenschaf In: Prinzip Verantwortung - Wege zu einer integralen Umweltwissenschaft Symposium in memoriam Hans Jonas, Evangelische Akademie Hofgeismar, Hofgeismar
- Judge, A.J.N., Uhlir, P.: (October 1993) Linking Hetereogeneous Environmetnal Data for Multipurpose Application: A Conceptual Superstructure, Working Sceleton: National Research Council, Commission on Physical Sciences, Mathematics, and Applications, Washington DC, Union of International Associations (UIS), Brussels, (draft to be used for Ottawa 1994)
- (1994) Bridges and a Masterplan for Islands of Data in a Labyrinth of Environmental and Economic Information - The UNEP - HEMIS Design proposal as a subset and Extention of Retrieval and Information Management Systems, 13th International Conferenceon Data for Science and Technology (CODATA) Conference "New Data Challenges in Our Information Age", International Council of Scientific Unions (ICSU), Beijing, 10/1992, under review (GeoJournal '94)
- , Fliedner, T.M., Radermacher, F.J.: (March 1994) Health-Net and other Collaboratory Research proposals for ACGHR, International Institute for Scientific Cooperation, WHO-Collaborating Center for Global Modeling of Health Perspectives, Schloß Reisensburg (some documents are available on request as presented to the Director General of the UN).
- , Greiner, C.: (June 1994), Proposing a Conceptual Superstructure - A concept to index, link, and view highly differentiated, multi-scale, multi-media, multi-lingual information in the area of environmental education, research, policy, and management, 1st International Symposium on Ecosystem Health & Medicine-Integrating Science, Policy and Management, Ottawa
- (1994), Visual Access and Assimilation strategies for prestructuring bodies of knowledge - Proposals and lessens learned, Environmental Knowledge Organization and Information Management, Classification, Terminology, Thesauri, and Software, ISKO - International Society of Knowledge Organization, Bratislawa, Slowakia, September 14-16 (under preparation)
- , Kaiser, A.: (1994) Mapping Issues and their Context, their Proportions and Consequences, A framework to communicate critical issues like overpopulation, under preparation for UNFPA Cairo Population Conference in September 1994.
Bestougeff, H., Dubois, J.E.: (1990) New Perspectives in Scientific Complex Data Management; CODATA Bulletin, 22.4
BMFT: (December 1985) Report of the Technology, Growth and Employment Working Group on further steps regarding "Improvement and Harmonization of Practices of Environmental Measurement" to the Tokyo Economic Summit 1986, Bonn
Bohm, D., Capra F., Ferguson, M., Pribam, K.H., Wilber, K.: (1982) The Holographic Paradigm and other paradoxes. - Das holographische Weltbild , Shambhala Publications, Boston
Bonnet, A.: (March 1992) Journal of the Association for Global Strategic Information
Brown, G.S.:(1992) Laws of Form.- New York
Brown, N J.:( March 1994) AGENDA 21: Blueprint for Global Sustainability, New Opportunities for Earth Systems Management, 7th Remote Systems Conference, Melbourne, Australia
Busch-Lüty, Ch; Dürr, H.-P.:(1993) Ökonomie und Natur: Versuch einer Annäherung im interdisziplinären Dialog, In: (ed.: Heinz König), Umweltverträgliches Wirtschaften als Problem von Wissenschaft und Politik, Duncker & Humblot - Berlin, Band 224, 13-44
Byrne, P.: (February 1993) The Surveyor, The Environment and AGENDA 21, Land Management & Environmental Policies task force, Published by FIG Secretary General, New Orleans
Cant, R.G.: (1991) The Dilemma of Historical Geography, in: Historical Geography. A methodological Portrayal (Brooks Green, D. eds.), Savage reprinted from Johnson W.B., Maryland
Castri, di F., Hadley, M.:(1985,1986,1988) Enhancing the Credibility of Ecology: Geojournal TRILOGY, Vol. 11.4, 321-328, (1985), Vol. 13.4, 299-325, (1986) Vol. 17.1, 3-35 (1988)
Chorley, R.J., Hagget, P.(eds.): (1965) Frontiers in geographic teaching, Methuen, London
CODATA:(1990) Directions for Internationally Compatible Environmental Data, ICSU, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, New York
CONNEX: (März 1994) Die Überwindung der babylonischen Sprachverwirrung, (editorial and titel-story:) CONNEX - Österreichische Fachzeitschrift für nationale, europäische und internationale Normen, 4-8
Committee on Earth and Environmental Sciences and FCCSET:( September 1972) The U.S. Global Change Data and Information Management Program; Washington
Connors 'O, J.C.: ( 1994) WORLD BANK, personal communication to a number of people in regard to "what is going on"
Croze, H.:(Sept/Oct 1983) The Sectoral Data Trap, In: Global Monitoring and Biosphere Reserves, Chapter 6, Global and Regional Monitoring, In: Conservation, Science, and Society; Natural Resources, and Research XXI, Vol. II, First International Biosphere Congress Minsk/USSR, UNEP/UNESCO, FAO/IUCN, ISBN 92-3-102254-7
ICSU-CODATA: (1992) Data for Discovery: 12. ICSU-CODATA Conference, (eds. Phyllis Glaeser), Begell House, ISBN 1- 56700-002-9
Dahlberg, W.: (1980) Wissensstrukturen und Ordnungsmuster, IDEX VERLAG, Frankfurt
Dahlberg, I.: (1982) ICC -Information Coding Classification, Principles structures and application possibilities. Int. Classif.) no.3, p.87-93, also in Classification Systems and Thesauri 1950-1982. ICIB-1. Frankfurt, Indeks Verlag 1982, p.107-132
Dahlberg, I.: (1992) Knowledge Organization and Terminology: Philosophical and Linguistic Bases.- In: International Classification, Vol. 19, 1992, No. 2, S.65-71
Dahlberg, I.: (1994) Wissensorganisation - eine neue Wissenschaft? In: "Begriffliche Wissensverarbeitung vom 24.-26.2.1994,Darmstadt
DeSanctis,G. (1984), Computer Graphics and Decision Aids: Directions for Research, In: Decision Sciences 15, 463-487
Didsbury Jr., Howard F.: (1982) Communications and the future - Prospects, Promises, and Problems, World Future Society, Bethesda Maryland
Directory of Organizations and Institutes Active in Environmental Monitoring, first Edition, UNEP-HEM, Munich, 1992
Directory of Global and Regional Data Sets Supporting Global Change Research; Project Summary; National Geophysical Data Centre (NOAA/NESDIS/EGC1), Boulder April 1989
Doxiades, C.A.:(1968) Ekistics - An Introduction to the Science of Human Settlement, Athens Center of Ekistics of the Athens Technological Institute
EARTHWATCH, UNEP-GEMS: (June 1991),Towards the Design for a Meta-database for Harmonization of Environmental Measurement, Report of the Expert Group Meeting, Report Series 8, UNEP-HEM July 26-27, 1990, Nairobi
EARTHWATCH, UNEP-GEMS Report Series, USER REQUIREMENTS for the Harmonization of Environmental Measurement Information System HEMIS, in press
EEA-TF, DGXI: (1994): Environmental Information, under preparation, draft: Februar 1993
EEES Report (Environmental Experts of the Economic Summit) on Current International Scientific Activities in Improvement and Harmonization of Techniques and Practices of Environmental Measurement, GSF-PFU Secretariat, Munich, 1986
EEES Report on Priority Areas for Improvement and Harmonization ... Final Report including Summit Declarations , GSF-PFU Secretariat, Munich, June 1987
Ellyard, P.: The Emerging Planetary Paradigm: Professionalism for an Independent Planetary 21st Century, FIG XX, Melbourne 1994
Environmental Information Statement, International Forum for Environmental Information for the Twenty-First Century, Montreal 1991
Executive Office of the President: Data Management for Global Change Research Policy Statements, Office of Science and Technology (1991)
EYELESS IN GAIA: (March 1990) The State of Enviromental Monitoring, World Resources Institute, Washington D.C.
Faßler, M.: (1992) Bewertungskrise oder Ernüchterung? - Zu soziokulturellen Bewertungsdifferenzen von Querschnittsproblemen, In: Technik, Öffentlichkeit und Verantwortung, (= Wissensverarbeitung und Gesellschaft, Bd. 3/Publikationsreihe des FAW), Ulm
Faßler, M.: (1992) Hypothetical Mechanism. Evolutionary Ecology as a non Trivial Regime, WHO-Tagung vom 10.9.1992
Feather, F., Rashmi, V., Mayour, N.: Communications for Global Development - Closing the Information Gap
Frey, G.: (1992) Die schöpferischen Kräfte des Menschen - Künstlerische und wissenschaftlich-technische Gestaltung der Welt, In: Mensch, Natur, Gesellschaft, Vol. 9.12, 3-20, SOLARIS Verlag, Innsbruck
Fuller, R. Buckminster: (1975/1982) Synergetics; explorations in the geometry of thinking, New York, Collier, 2 vols
Galinski, C., Budin, G., Krommer-Benz, M., Manu, A.: (1991) Terminology Planning and the Knowledge Industries, In: Language Policies in Europe 111rd Symposium, European Parliament, 30.5-1.6. 1991, Wien: TermNet, 1991, 7p., (Infoterm, no 13-91en)
Garfield, E.: (1981) Discipline-oriented citation indexes and databases: bridging the interdisciplinary gap via multidisciplinary input, Current Contents 3, 5-8
GEMS Meeting Reports No. 2: (December 1987) UNEP Expert Meeting on Improvement and Harmonization of Environmental Measurement, Munich
Gordon, T.T., Glenn, J.: (1993) Issues in Creating the Millenium.Project (ed. by the United Nations University) Washington
Grossmann, W. D.: (1983) Systems approaches towards complex systems. In: Messerli, P., Strucki, E.: (eds.), Fachbeiträge der schweizerischen MAB Informationen 19, Bundesamt für Umweltschutz, Bern
Grossmann, W. D.:(März 1993) Wissenschaftliche, technische und Erziehungsaufgaben der Institutionen, VDI Expertentreffen, Düsseldorf
Grossmann, W.D.: (July 1994) Dynamische Modelle zur sozio-ökonomischen Zukunftsgestaltung, UBA Berlin
Günther, O., Radermacher F.J., Riekert, W.F.: (1993) Umweltmonitoring: Modelle, Methoden und Systeme, In: B. Page, L. Hilty (Hrsg.), Umweltinformatik. Handbuch der Informatik. München
Hartshorne, R.:(1959) Perspectives of Nature in Geography, Rand Macnally, Chicago
Henderson, H.: (1991) Paradigms in Progress - Life Beyond Economics, Knowledge Systems, Inc., ISBN 0-941705-21-8
Halbach, W. R.:(1992) Gegen den Mythos virtueller Realitäten, In: Technik, Öffentlichkeit und Verantwortung, Wissensverarbeitung und Gesellschaft, Bd. 3, FAW, Ulm
Halbach, W. R.: (1992) Kontexte der Umweltinformatik - Anmerkungen zu den blinden Flecken einer ökologischen Technik, In: Günther, O., Kuhn, H., Mayer-Föll, R. Radermacher, F.J. (Hrsg.), Konzeption und Einsatz von Umweltinformationssystemen, (= Informatik Fachberichte 301), 147-168, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg
Harley, W.: The McBride Commission Report: Issues and Processes in Global Communiation, UNESCO 1976
Hesse, Hermann: Das Glasperlenspiel. The Glass Bead Game.- Cape, London 1969
Hoetker, Glenn P.: (June 1991) , Why is Japanese scientific and technical information so hard to find and use? - Warum sind japanische naturwissenschaftliche und technische informationen so schwierig zu finden und zu benutzen?; In: NfD 43, 76-82 (1992) or Proceedings 82. Annual Conference of the Special Libraries Association, Texas,
Husserl, Edmund: (1973), Ding und Raum, Vorlesungen 1907, Husserlianer Bd. XVI, Nijhoff 1973
Ichikawa, T. et al. (edd.) (1990), Visual Languages and Applications, New York, Plenum Press
ICSU-CODATA, (1991), A Glossary of terms relating to DATA, DATA CAPTURE, DATA MANIPULATION, and DATABASES: Westbrook, J.H., Grattige, W., Westrum, E. (eds.), Paris
ICSU: (November 1991), An Agenda of Science for Environment and Development into the 21st Century, Cambridge Univ. Press, Vienna
Infoterm Series 6, (1981), Theoretical and methodological Problems of Terminology, K.G. Saur, Munich
Infoterm Series 7, (1982), Terminology's for the Eighties, K.G. Saur, Munich 1982
INTERCOCTA Glossary, see: Riggs, F.W.
Isenmann, W.D., Reuter, W.D., Schulz K.-P.: (1992), HyperIBIS - Ein Informationssystem zur Umweltplanung, In: Informatik für den Umweltschutz, 6. Syposium, Informatik Fachberichte, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg
Isenmann, S.: (1992), Hypertext als Werkzeug für das Informationsmanagement im Umweltbereich, In: Günther, O., Kuhn, H., Mayer-Föll, R. Radermacher, F.J. (eds.), Konzeption und Einsatz von Umweltinformationssystemen, Informatik, Fachberichte 301, 253-261, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg
Isenmann, S.: (1993), How to deal with wicked problems using a new type of Information System, In: Systems Science: Addressing Global Issues, Stowell, F.A., West, D., Howell, G. (eds.) 367-372, Plenum, New York
Jaenecke, P.: (1994), To what End Knowledge Processing? In: Knowledge Organization - Vol 21, No.1, S.3-11
Jaeschke, A., Keitel, A., Mayer-Föll, R., Radermacher, F.J., Seggelke, J.: (1992) Metawissen als Teil von Umweltinformationssystemen, In: Günther, O., Kuhn, H., Mayer-Föll, R. Radermacher, F.J. (eds.), Konzeption und Einsatz von Umweltinformationssystemen, Informatik, Fachberichte 301, 113-130, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg
Jeffers, J.N.R.: (1978), An Introduction to System Analysis, Arnold, London
Johnson, W.B.: (1969), Human Geography: Concepts and Case Studies, 40-60. Christchurch, University of Canterbury
Judge, A.J.N.: (1973), Towards a Concept Inventory, COCTA - Commitee on Conceptual and Terminological Analysis, Montreal, August 1973 - International Political Science Association, Union of International Associations, Brussels
- (1984), Functional Classification, I and II Int. Classification. 11, p.69-76, No.3. p. 139-150
- (November, 1991), Metaphors as transdisciplinary Vehicles of the Future, UIA, Brussels, not published
- (Nov 1991), Research Network on Catalytic Imagery for Governance in Impossible Situations, UIA, Brussels, Draft Proposal, not published
- , Koshla, A., Slaughter, R., Dahlberg, I.: (1992), Catalyzation of new patterns of Caollaboration using a PC-based structural outliner as an imaging scaffold, UIA, Brussels, not published
- (1993) Visualizing Relationship Networks - International, Interdisciplinary, Intersectoral; In: Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential, 3. Auflage, Union of International Associations (UIA), K.G. Saur Verlag, München
Kampffmeyer, U.: (November 1991) Descriptoren versus Volltext, DGD/LID Tagung, Frankfurt "Strategien für optical Filing - Anwendungen im Pressearchiv, Frankfurt
- ., Benking, H.: ( July 1990) Global Information Systems: Design, Classification and Multi-lingual Thesauri Development, Issues and Concepts Related to the Task of Meta-Database Development, 1. Expert Group Meeting, unpublished, UNEP-HEM
- (1992) Von der Datenverarbeitung zur Integrierten Informationsverarbeitung: Welchen Beitrag kann "Optical Filing" leisten? Congress V, 10.02, ONLINE ´92, 15. International Congress Fair for Technical Communications, Hamburg, 10. -14. 2. 1992, ISBN 3-89077-106-8
- (1993) Multilinguale Retrieval- und Informationssysteme: Technik und Beispiele, ONLINE ´93 Congress IV, C430, Hamburg
Kant, Immanuel: (1911) Kritik der reinen Vernunft, Ges. Schriften III, Berlin
Keune, H.; Murray, A. B., Benking, H.: (March 1991) Harmonization of Environmental Measurement, GeoJournal, 23.3, 249-255, Kluwer Academic Publishers
- , Kampffmeyer, U. B., Benking, H., Theisen, A.: (October 1991), Discussion Paper for the 2. Expert Group Meeting, UNEP-HEM Meta-Database and Information System HEMIS, hand-out unpublished, UNEP-HEM
- , Kampffmeyer, U., Benking, H.: (August 1992), HEMIS - A Meta-Database and Information System with Multiple and Multi-Lingual Access Strategies, Presentation and Demonstration hand-out, UN-ISY Conference, Boulder
Krushanov, A.A.:(1993), The Picture of the World and Knowledge Organization, In: Knowledge Organization, Vol. 20, No. 4, S. 192
Kuhns, W.: Twice as Natural - Speculations on the Emerging Information Culture
Kunz, W., Rittel, H.W.: (1970), Issues as Elements of Information Systems, Center of Planning and Development Research, Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California
Lakoff, G.: (1987), Women, Fire, and other dangerous things - What categories reveal about the mind, The University of Chicago Press, ISBN 0-226-46803-8
Lamb, J.: (1989), Putting Semantics Into Data Capture, ECSC-EEC-EAEC, Brüssel
Lamson, Robert W.: (1981), Planning and Using Situation Rooms, World Future Society Bulletin Vol. 15.2, pp 4-11 March/April
Lange, M.; Benking, H. et. al.: (1990), Global Change - Welt im Wandel, Travelling Exhibition prepared by the Association of National Research Centers (AGF) to be shown first in the German Chancellery on the occasion of the Visite of the (international) White House Conference on Global Change, Bonn (scripts and translations are available from AGF and the author)
Langran, G.: (1992), Time in geographic information systems, Taylor&Francis
Lancaster, F.I.:(1986), Vocabulary Control for Information Retrieval, Resources Press, Arlington
Landau; S.I.:(1984), Dictionaries: The Art and Craft of Lexicography, Scribers Sons, New York
Levitus, S.:(July 1992), Data Archaeology & Rescue Project, IOC/IODE-XIV/13, Paris
Lookeren Campagne, van Ir. N.:(1992), World Sciences contribution to N.W. European Policy making on Environmental Issues, Ökologie Dialog, Bonn
Luhmann, N.: (1991), Soziologie des Risikos, de Gruiter, Berlin, New York
MacGregor, J.N., Lee, E.S.: (1988), A Feature Matching Approach to the Retrieval of Graphical Information, In: Behavior and Information Technology 7, 457-465
Maturana H.R.:( 1982), Erkennen: Die Organisation und Verkörperung von Wirklichkeit - Ausgewählte Arbeiten zur biologischen Epistemologie, Vieweg Verlag
Mainka, M.:(1994) Unbemerkte Wirklichkeit - Auf den Spuren von Jakob von Uexküll (1864-1944), Kompositionslehre der Natur, Kino-Film Hamburg - München
Marien, M.: (1962), Non-Communication and the future, Computopia
Markowitz, J.: (1992), Das Problem der Paradoxien und die Semantik des Risikos, In: Technik, Öffentlichkeit und Verantwortung, Wissensverarbeitung und Gesellschaft, Bd. 3, FAW, Ulm
Miller, I.M.: (1969), Computer Graphics for Decision Making, In: Harvard Business Review, 121-132
Molenaar, M.:(1993) Object Hierarchies and Uncertainty in GIS or why is standardisation so difficult?, GIS 4, 22-28
Morawa, H.:(1979), Mut zur Utopie - Die Zukunft in den Griff bekommen, Econ Verlag, Düsseldorf -Wien, ISBN 3 430 16808 2
Morawa, H.:(May 1989), No Problem, the answer's here, Business Times, Management section
NRC - Committee on a National Collaboratory: (1993), Developing the User-Developer Partnership: National Collaboratories - Applying Information Technology for Scientific Research, National Academy Press, Washington D.C.
Oldemeyer, E.:(1992) Intuition, In: Mensch, Natur, Gesellschaft, Vol. 9.12, 38-44, SOLARIS Verlag, Innsbruck
Peters, E.:(1992), Building Trans-European Networks, TEDIS II, EDI 92, Germany, Hamburg
Popper, K.R. : (1972) Objektive Erkenntnis - Ein evolutionärer Entwurf, Hoffmann und Campe, Hamburg
Radermacher, F.J.:(1991), Überlegungen zur künftigen Informationsgesellschaft, IBM Hochschulkolloquium "Szenario 2000 - Technik und Gesellschaft", Sindelfingen
- (1991) The Importance of Meta-Knowledge for Environmental Information Systems, In: Günther, O., Schek, H.J. (eds). Advances in Spacial Databases, Lecture Notes in Computer Sciences no. 525, Springer Verlag, Berlin
- (1991), Von der Artificial Intelligence zu neuronalen Netzen, In: Man and Technology, European Forum on Technology, Carinthia, 35-50, Klagenfurt
Research Institute for Information and Knowledge:(1992), The List of Multifield-Common and Multilingual Basic Terms in Science and Technology, Kanagawa University, Tokyo
Riedel, R., (1992), Begriff und Welt, Biologische Grundlagen des Erkennens und Begreifens, Paul Parey, Hamburg - Berlin
Riedel, R., (1992), Die Spaltung des Weltbildes, Biologische Grundlagen des Erklärens und Verstehens, Paul Parey , Hamburg - Berlin
Riggs, F.W.:(1985) Ethnicity, Intercocta Glossary, Concepts and Terms used in Ethnicity Research (pilot edition), International Conceptual Encyclopedia for the Social Science, Vol. 1
Schwitte, J.:(1991), Ökologie - Umweltschutz - Überlebenskrise, Ein interdisziplinäres Konzept für einführende Grundlagenvorträge, fachliche Fortbildungsveranstaltungen, wissenschaftliche Intensivkurse, Eigenverlag, Hamburg
Schulz, K.P.:(1992), Konzeption des FAW- Projekts ZEUS, In: Günther, O., Kuhn, H., Mayer-Föll, R. Radermacher, F.J. (eds.), Konzeption und Einsatz von Umweltinformationssystemen, Informatik, Fachberichte 301, 113-130, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg
Siu, F.: (1994), Pantetics- Trilogy, International Society of Panetics, ISBN 1-884437-00-1, Washington D.C.
Smoker, P.:(1993), Prospects for Peace in the 21st Century: Changing Models - Changing Realities, Paper prepared for the XII. World Futures Study Federation World Conference, Panels on Globalization/Localization, WFSF, Turku, Finland
Soergel, :(1971), Documentation und Organisation des Wissens - Versuch einer methodischen und theretischen Grundlegung am Beispiel der Sozialwissenschaften, Berlin: Duncker & Humblot
Stoddart, D.R.: (1965), Geography and the Ecological Appraoch: The Ecosystem as a geographic Principle and Method, Geography, 50, 242-251
Stoddart, D.R.:(1967), Organism and Ecosystem as Geographical Models, in: Chorley and Haggett eds. 511-548
Transley, A.G.: (1935), The Use and Abuse of Vegetational Conceps and Terms, Ecology, 16, 284-307
Tikell, C.:(Dec. 1993), The Earth Summit: a year later, RSA Journal, Vol.CXLII, No. 5445, 38-46
UIA: ENCYCLOPEDIA OF WORLD PROBLEMS AND HUMAN POTENTIAL, Vol.1 World Problems, Vol. 2, Human Potential, 3rd Edition, München, New York, London, Paris 1991, - on CD-ROM available in 1994
UNEP-HEM:(June 1991), Information about Environmental Information, Presentation and Prepartion July, 1990 of a meta-database expert group meeting, original concepts and possible contributors, UNEP - EARTHWATCH, in GEMS report series No 8, Nairobi
UNESCO, General Information Programme and UNISIST: (1992), Transborder Datflow of Library and Information Services - An overview and a policy checklist, prepared by Wysocki, A. for IFLA, Paris
UNESCO-UNEP (FAO-IUCN):(1984), Conservation, Science and Society - First International Biosphere Reserves Congress, Minsk, ISBN 92-3-102254-7, Paris
UNISIST:(May 1980), Guidelines for the Establishment and Development of Multi-Lingual Thesauri, UNESCO, Paris
van Sommers, P.: (1984), Drawing and Cognition, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Vieser, H. Benking, H.: (1989), Umweltschutz mit Adlerblick - Die fliegende Lupe, Bild der Wissenschaft, S. 36-43, 6/89
Weber, Marcel:(1991?), Faszination und Unverständlichkeit der Naturwissenschaft - Brauchen die Naturwissenschaften eine bessere Öffentlichkeit?, Bulletin der Schweizerischen Akademie der Geistes- und Sozialwissenschaften und der Schweizer Akademie der Naturwissenschaften, Bern
Weinberg A.:(1963), Weinberg Report: Science, Government, and Information - The Responsibility of the Technical Community and the Government in the Transfer of Information. A Report of the President's Science Advisory Commitee, Washington DC, The White House, (USGPO)
Weizsäcker v., E. U.:(1988), Ganzheitlicher Umweltschutz, In: Jaeschke, A., Page, B. (eds.), Informatikanwendungen im Umweltbereich, Informatik Fachberichte 170, S. 1-7, Springer, Heidelberg
Weizsäcker, v., C.F.: (1992), Die Konsequenzen der Wissenschaft ernstnehmen, In: Mensch, Natur, Gesellschaft, Vol. 9.12, 3-20, SOLARIS Verlag, Innsbruck
Wessel, A.: (1975), Information Retrieval und Automatisierung, Luchterhand, Böblingen-Sindelfingen
Wilber, K. (ed.) Bohm, D., Capra,F., Ferguson, M., Pribam, K.H.,:( 1982), The Holographic Paradigm and other Paradoxes, Shambhala Publications, Boston
FAW Ulm, Postfach 2060
D-89010 Ulm, Germany
Tel: +49 731 501 -910, FAX: - 999